Monthly Archives: February 2016

The Art and Science of Selling

Older readers will remember the adverts that began with a doorbell: “Ding Dong” and will immediately respond: “Avon calling”.  The point of the advert was to soften up the viewers for the “Avon Lady”, when she called.  How many have even noticed that practitioners of the art and science of selling on the doorstep have disappeared?  Very few people these days sell from door to door.

It seems doorstep selling began with the Fuller Brush Company in the United States.  They were the origin of the term “foot-in-the-door”.  Many companies, including Avon Cosmetics, copied the Fuller Brush Company and it seems a good salesperson was often a welcome visitor, building long-term relationships with their customers.  However, the current image is of the brash salesperson who will not take no for an answer.  Where have they gone?

It seems it’s the Internet what’s done for them!  Whether this is a blessing or a curse probably depends on whether you believe Internet sales are better or worse than doorstep sales!

Daniel Pink in his book “To Sell is Human: The Surprising Truth About Persuading Convincing and Influencing Others” (subtitle from 2014 edition) charts the decline of doorstep selling and the surprising rise of selling in general.  His point is not that Internet sales have usurped the place of doorstep sales but that we are all salespeople now.  Or most of us!

His argument is other changes apart from the rise of the Internet mean we are all practitioners of the art and science of selling now.  He highlights three trends that have led to this change.  The archetypal doorstep salesperson has given way to the professional who incorporates selling into their daily work and perhaps is not aware they are doing so.  I suppose it depends on how you think about your work.  I’ll mention his three main trends here and comment on how they relate to the local economy.

Entrepreneurs

Every local business is dependent on selling its product service or cause.  This is most obvious with retailers perhaps but there are plenty of self-employed freelancers who must learn how to sell.

The self-employed, who abandon employment to sell their skills and knowledge, are sometimes called the precariat.  Many are not very good at sales and barely cover their costs.  Many are not successful and either change their practice until they find something that works or go under.

The problem for many entrepreneurs is believing what they offer has real social value.  It is hard to sell something you don’t believe in.  Their failure to believe in their own offer does not necessarily correlate with what they offer.  For every brash salesperson selling something over-hyped there is the too timid entrepreneur who never quite convinces about something that is really rather good!

Successful businesses usually find a business community who offer support and bolster confidence to sell.  Whilst some businesses could benefit from a healthy dose of brashness, perhaps it is quiet confidence in a good product or service that ultimately wins out.  And perhaps many businesses would benefit from other businesses singing their praises!

Selling in the Community

Community and voluntary organisations are often in a similar place to local businesses.  They may be selling a cause and so they are not necessarily seeking finance but they are still engaged in sales.  Perhaps the main difference between these organisations and local businesses is that usually, they are not dependent on the success of their enterprise.  People promoting a local cause will often do so in their spare time, whilst remaining in employment.

Leaving aside possible clashes with their employers over the cause they promote, the primary difference may be lack of experience.  Many will think of their selling as promoting a cause or campaigning and do not associate it with the marketing local businesses do.

Nevertheless, there is a lot of common ground and perhaps mutual recognition and sympathy would lead to more collaboration.  Businesses may be able to help organisations with marketing, whilst some community organisations may have valuable local knowledge.

Elastic Businesses

Entrepreneurs can find they are marketing alongside representatives from more established businesses.  These are not from the sales department because many larger businesses have done away with their sales departments, flattened hierarchies and declared that everyone is responsible for sales.  Many workers find their role stretches to cover far more than they would in the past and everyone has some role in promoting their company.

Selling through your role in your business is increasingly your responsibility.  If in promoting your role, you bring more customers to the business it is all to the good.

Many workers are waking up to the fact that they belong to a community.  It may be local, perhaps a city or region or it may be online.  They are part of a community, customers and collaborators who may bring customers to the company.  The challenge is to navigate the sea of people who seem to be creative on a shoestring.  Building relationships with entrepreneurs, third sector and in business, can bring greater benefits to larger companies.

Education and Medicine

Pink’s point here is that not all selling involves money.  The aim is to persuade others to take a course of action for their own benefit.  So, a teacher needs to sell learning to their pupils or students.  A doctor needs to persuade patients to change their diet to help them return to health.

By extension just about any activity needs a sales approach.  Community and voluntary organisations often find they are marketing a cause.   They may want donations or time or members or signatures or letters to MPs.  How do they move people to support their cause?

Sample Cases

After he makes the case that selling is a natural part of being human, Pink goes on to show how it can be done.  This is the best part of the book, as Pink describes the characteristics of a good salesperson and suggests practical exercises to improve their approach to sales.

Sample Cases follow each chapter, practical things anyone can take up and use.  So, this is essentially a practical book packed with simple tools anyone can use.  I suspect it is something I shall return to many times.

If you are active in local marketing you will find this book a useful practical guide to the art of selling.

Are you comfortable with being a salesperson?  If you are in any business or profession, you are almost certainly expected to sell things.  How do you go about it?

Resources of Public, Private and Non-Profit Institutions

I’m drawing on my experience of community development to consider six categories of community assets, and the third is public, private and non-profit institutions. You can find the full list towards the end of my post, What Are Community Assets?

Last time I suggested local associations can be assets or liabilities and so can other organisations active in a neighbourhood.

  • Public bodies can include members or officers from the local authority, health and social services, schools, the police and various government schemes. Some employ officers they call community workers who are often workers in the community and not always development workers. The resources these organisations bring into a neighbourhood can be significant although they often raise accountability issues.
  • Professional voluntary organisations, including not-for-profits, can make significant contributions of resources and expertise to a neighbourhood. Sometimes these grow out of local activity, committed to a particular neighbourhood. They may have local roots but perhaps do not count as community associations because they may be run by employees from outside the neighbourhood who bring in valuable expertise.  There are a range of these third sector organisations and they contribute to communities in various ways.  The link is to a page that offers more details.
  • Private Bodies are often committed to a neighbourhood but they are rarely recognised for the contribution they make. Occasionally a business owner might join a local association and sometimes local traders form a traders’ group. It is not unknown for local businesses to support community activity in creative ways but it is rare. Partly this is to do with the expectations of local organisations who naturally turn to the public sector as allies.

If a neighbourhood has a social enterprise based there, committed to working for the benefit of the area, the chances are it will have extensive networks into all three of these types of organisation. Local partnerships can marshal resources and enable all interested parties to contribute to a single plan for the area. Find My Three Function Model for more details.

Community Plans

The Local Government Act 2000 in the UK required local authorities to publish a community plan. As far as I can tell no later Local Government Acts rescinded this legislation, although there is variation in the extent to which local authorities carry them out.

These community plans theoretically bring together all sectors, including community associations, to plan for their local area. What forms a local area, seems to vary from council to council. Some produce a single plan for the local authority area. Others base this plan on plans for neighbourhoods within the Local Authority.

These local plans are an opportunity to get all the sectors around the table to work out the best ways to deploy public sector resources. This may work if the local authority puts resources into making it happen; perhaps less likely to happen in this era of austerity.

It is harder to start this type of planning at neighbourhood level, because community associations and social enterprises do not usually command the resources local authorities can bring to the table.

However, creative community organisations and social enterprises can bring together partners to work on specific projects.

One of the dilemmas facing many community organisations is mission creep.  If an external organisation brings assets into a neighbourhood, how can the priorities of local residents be honoured under these circumstances?  Can you share stories of creative cross-sectoral work that affirms local priorities?  How did you get back on course after the inevitable drift away from local priorities?

From One-Off to Repeated Sales

Repeated sales are the Holy Grail of Internet Marketing. If you have a good product or a service and it is possible to create a good digital version, you can sell it on-line. Many of the get-rich-quick schemes promoted by Internet marketers involve repeated sales.

I would never dissuade someone from trying this if they have a suitable product or service. However, there are a lot of second-rate offers online. Most people are better at providing one-off services or products.

A Case Study – for Repeated Sales

I am aware of one organisation that has provided an excellent service for over forty years. Over that time they have generated a lot of really useful information, they have a pool of people, mostly casual, who design and deliver the service and a list of members and contacts, satisfied customers who have in the past made donations and interest-free loans to the organisation.

Potentially they have a global market and could extend their list and probably find customers who would buy most of what they produced because they support the organisation.

In every respect this organisation could easily market its service online. The organisation is making an annual loss and will in a few years cease to trade. The reason they won’t market online is because they value the personal nature of the service they provide.

Whilst I understand their concern, I think they have made the wrong decision for two reasons. First, whilst delivering the service online may not be as personal as delivering it in person, it is not the same as an impersonal service. There are many ways an online service can be made more personal.

Second, delivering online products and services does not rule out delivering an in-person service. The organisation knows this but has not understood that an online service could subsidise their in-person work. It could in practice lead to increased in-person work.

Of course, these are judgements that have to be made all the time and it is not always easy to get them right. My approach would be to generally encourage organisations that have something genuinely first-rate to roll it out to the biggest possible audience. If it is that good, then the world needs to have access to it.

Developing Ideas

But what if you are developing an idea?  The chances are you are not ready to build a repeat sales product until you are confident you have designed a service that warrants it.  It is not too difficult to produce a high-quality one-off service. You need skills, experience and knowledge but if you have them you are most likely able to find packages that sell and are worth the money.

The hard thing is turning these packages into products that can be repeatedly sold. Not only does the package itself need to be high quality but also you need to be able to market it.

So, here are some intermediate steps you can take to test your market. Products you give away at first can be withdrawn and revised and incorporated into a premium package at a later date.

  • An ebook is a good way to test the market and grow your email list.
  • There are a variety of on-line documents, eg reports, guides, resource lists, diagrams, infograms …
  • A blog can be used to grow readers and encourage comments.
  • Videos can be made available through YouTube and used to build your email list.
  • Audio is good for things like meditations. People use them when jogging or driving.

None of these are likely to generate much income alone but they can be used to test your market and build email lists. They help you practice turning your activities into products and can be used to test a future premium product and perhaps incorporated into a premium product at a later date.

For most products be cautious about the value of what you can put together. Many services deliver for their clients and never put anything online. One reason for this will be that they lack the material someone will value and be able to use without expert guidance.

This is part of a post sequence about the second element of the circuit questionnaire, products services and causes.